By Tony Best
CLICO, the embattled Caribbean
Insurance company, broke Barbados’ laws
when it sold millions of dollars in annuities
to Barbadians in recent times, long after it
was barred from writing policies.
And the Supervisor of Insurance in
Barbados may have to deal with that thorny
problem.That blunt assessment has come from
William Layne, Permanent Secretary of
Barbados' Ministry of Finance and Chairman
of the Oversight Committee set up by the
Thompson Administration to study CLICO’s
finances. He told the Carib News in New
York after attending an investment insurance
seminar sponsored by Invest Barbados that
clearly CLICO had sold annuities at a time
when it had been specifically told not to
do so.
“They didn’t have authority to sell those
policies, so in fact they were doing something
illegal, the company was doing something
illegal,” was the way Layne put it.
As for the policy-holders, Bajans who
are holding corporate paper from CLICO
indicating that they had put their money into
the company, Layne was quick to say that
their interest was being protected by the
Supervisor of Insurance.
“In so far as the policy holders (are
concerned) they have the protection of the
Supervisor of Insurance under the law,” he
said. Layne, an accountant and a highly
respected civil servant known for his insistence
on following rules and regulation,
regardless of who or what was involved, disagreed
with former Prime Minister, Owen
Arthur, who was quoted several days ago as
saying that the annuity policy holders were
now holding worthless pieces of paper.
“I wouldn’t say the policies are worthless,
they wouldn’t be,” Layne declared. “I
can’t say what options they are under the law
because I am not that cognizant of that aspect
of the law. I think people would have bought
the policies in good faith but the fact that the
company had no authority to sell them is
another matter.”
Dr. David Estwick, Minister of
Economic Affairs, who delivered the feature
address at the seminar in Manhattan attended
by scores of American executives, Barbados
government officials and Bajans in New
York said that the annuity issue and other
CLICO matters were being considered by the
Oversight Committee led by Layne and he
would await the panel’s recommendations
before commenting on the next move.
“There is the oversight committee dealing
with this matter. I think the former Prime
Minister has the right to interpret the way he
sees it,” asserted Dr. Estwick. “I think the
oversight committee has a job to do and they
are doing that job and I can only await the
conclusions and the various reports of the
Committee. From that data I would then have
to infer one way or another whether they are
valid pieces of paper or if they are waste as
the former Prime Minister would have said.”